I’m pretty sure Philadelphia has a housing problem, too

Next City has a new piece poking a hole in Philadelphia’s latest affordable housing initiative:

But it isn’t really a housing problem — it’s an income problem.

The housing itself is quite cheap here compared to most of Philadelphia’s peer cities. The real issue is the 28.4 percent poverty rate, one of the highest in the nation. Cheap as the housing is in absolute terms, a sizable segment of the population still doesn’t earn enough money to afford it.

Which, fair enough. The fact that housing affordability can be broken down into two relatively distinct issues – housing costs, on the one hand, and income, on the other – is actually a really important point and, based on the income data the author provides for various neighborhoods in Philadelphia, it seems that the city does, in fact, have a major income problem.

(A “housing” problem exists when a city’s housing costs are higher than they should be, based on the cost of land and construction. That’s usually a result of artificially low density restrictions. An “income” problem is just when people can’t afford to pay for housing, even when its price is as low as the market can reasonably bear. See Glaeser and Gyourko’s Rethinking Federal Housing Policy for a longer, more involved explanation.)

But the fact that Philly has an income problem doesn’t mean that it doesn’t also have a housing problem. And I would bet a fair amount of money that it does.

For one, although the author shows that a variety of poor inner-city and gentrifying neighborhoods have very low rental costs, a quick jaunt over to Rich Blocks, Poor Blocks suggests that the wealthy central city and a large number of surrounding suburbs have much higher costs.

For two – and this is a point I wish would come up more in affordable housing conversations – it really doesn’t cut it for there to be affordable housing units if those units are largely in poor, segregated neighborhoods with high crime, terrible schools, and little access to basic amenities like, say, grocery and hardware stores. I haven’t been to Philadelphia, so I can’t speak from personal experience, so maybe I’m off base – but going off of the little I know (from anecdotal and more rigorous sources), that seems to be the situation, as it is in many large American cities. We should not, in a country with the resources and commitment to a high standard of living that we have, be satisfied that people can put a roof over their heads. The mandate, I think, is that they can live in a place that you, reader, would not be aghast to raise your children in. That doesn’t seem like so  much to ask.

So yes, by all means, let’s call attention to the fact that affordable housing, in most places, involves both fixing our housing policy and lifting incomes. But let’s not kid each other that the housing problem is fixed when so many of the places with the best access to the most basic accoutrements of a decent life are still off-limits.

One thought on “I’m pretty sure Philadelphia has a housing problem, too

  1. Re: “It really doesn’t cut it …”

    Yes, it does. I’m from Philadelphia, and I’ve lived in only the neighborhoods with bad reputations. Here’s a lifehack: those neighborhoods are fine.
    Like many products available to modern Americans, the difference between the low end and the high end is pretty small.
    LARGE PRICE DIFFERENCES MUST BE MANUFACTURED BY MARKETING. so too with housing. All the claptrap you read about the scary bad neighborhood is how people who are overpaying for housing tell themselves and each other their housing costs are worth something.
    The market actually does provide quite a lot of affordable housing. Part of the method relies on upper income people’s general horror of low income styles of life.
    Periodically the market’s provision of low income housing is frustrated. Area humanitarians will become so scandalized by poor areas, they evict the residents and demolish the market rate low income housing. Then they say, “the market can’t provide low income housing.” Lol. Grim.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s